WHICH TWIN IS THE TORY?
That was a Liberal slogan in 1966. It could apply again now.
Labour’s plan for compulsory national identity cards ought alone to be enough
for anyone who prizes liberty to strive to ensure its candidates’ defeat at the
expected general election. This vile assault on the country’s fundamental
freedoms is all of a piece with the Blairites’ determination to turn Britain
into a police state.
Only Labour candidates who have specifically repudiated both identity cards and
the Iraq war should benefit from Liberal Democrat tactical voting.
Labour authoritarianism comes from two sources – one is the party’s historic
conviction that the state knows best, a stance which, however objectionable, is
at least intellectually arguable.
The other is not. It comes from the spinelessness that defines the ‘new’ variant
of Labour. Faced with a populist clamour from right-wing tabloids for simplistic
‘action’, Labour is ready to destroy the country’s historic rights and liberties
rather than face down this bullying.
Identity cards (under which citizens will have to account to the police for
their lawful presence in a public place) and house arrest (for those of whom
Charles Clarke disapproves) are the worst examples.
But the list goes on, ranging from a treaty that allows British citizens to be
extradited on demand to America, through making criticism of religions illegal,
to abolition of the secret ballot in some elections.
Blair has presided over an onslaught against liberty on a scale undreamed of
even by the preceding Conservative government.
While he is quite willing to repulse any attack from the ‘left’, however widely
defined, Blair has never in his wretched career stood up to the right.
Whether it is the Conservative Party itself, the newspapers that support it, or
merely a transient opinion poll, he accommodates, rather than confronts, any
attack from the right. The result is a ratchet effect that pulls the whole of
political discourse inexorably to the authoritarian right.
The forces of conservatism that Blair once affected to oppose, but which in fact
he embraces warmly, thus only have to keep demanding more in order to secure
their goals. Since each time they demand something they are appeased by the
government, they naturally come back for more. Indeed, it is scarcely worth
exerting themselves to elect Tories when they can get what they want anyway from
Thus the coming general election will see a right-wing Labour Party fighting an
extreme right-wing Conservative one.
It is vital that the Liberal Democrats stand outside this. This is not just an
issue of principle, important as that is, but one of good politics.
Right-wing authoritarians have two parties from which to choose, and would
therefore have no reason to give their support to a third one.
But that part of the electorate that is neither conservative nor authoritarian,
and it is a large part, has nowhere to go but the Liberal Democrats.
Having for decades struggled to define itself clearly, the party now faces an
election in which its position is not only clear but is one that gives it sole
claim to the huge swathe of the progressively-minded electorate.
The Liberal Democrat position is about as distinctive as it could be: civil
liberty, good public services paid for by fair taxation, a justice system that
both punishes and rehabilitates, long-term environmental gains even though they
may require short-term inconvenience, a full role in a democratic European
Union, and a foreign policy independent of Washington.
With the possible exception of the latter, these are not positions that command
easy headlines or sound bites, or that fit into posturing about who is
But they do appeal to voters who think beyond simplistic slogans; who value
their services, freedom and environment; who hate this government’s interference
with liberty at home and craven behaviour abroad; and who know the Tories offer
On that base, the party can build the solid foundation of committed support -
rather than floating protest votes – that has so long eluded it. Solidify that,
and who knows what a future general election may hold.
Throw it away by trying to outbid the populism of the other two parties, and it
will be painfully obvious what future elections will hold.
The Liberal Democrats are in contention for the whole progressive vote, and the
party is largely united about its positions.
If it holds its nerve and resists siren calls from the right, it will enter the
expected general election in the best shape, and with the best prospects, it has
had in the lifetimes of most members.
YOUR NEXT LIBERATOR
Tony Blair has inexplicably failed to advise the Liberator
Collective of the date of the next general election.
If, as everyone at present expects, it falls on 5 May, we intend to produce an
issue in mid-April depending on how many people are available to contribute.
That may prove impossible, in which case Liberator 302 would appear after the
Click here to return to the home page.